The column: Miguel Ángel López vs the Slovenian

The column: Miguel Ángel López vs the Slovenian

Six of one, half a dozen of the other? Did the guy get what he deserved? Or should the UCI have thrown the book at Miguel Ángel López?

Giro d'Italia Giro d'Italia 2019 Miguel Angel Lopez Racing spectators

Whose side are you on? The puncher or the punched? What if we said you could choose both?

 

Miguel Ángel López certainly caused a commotion on Saturday when he took a few well-aimed swings at a spectator who inadvertently impeded him on the final climb of this year’s Giro d’Italia. Alternatively, an idiot finally got what he deserved when he got in the way of the race.

 

The UCI then made things worse by ignoring their own regulations and letting López off the hook. Or, the jury allowed reason, sanity and righteousness to prevail when they decided against imposing a sanction on the Colombian for what they correctly judged a “human reaction”.

 

Centrism is very unfashionable these days, and the room for nuance in our discourse is shoe box sized at best. But is it possible that neither of these positions is the correct one? That a just verdict may in fact resemble a combination of both? Might both parties even deserve some sympathy?

 

For it seems fair to assume that rider and fan were caught up in the excitement, stress and heat of the moment.

 

You can argue, if you like, that the spectator started it when he decided to run alongside the riders but 999 times out of 1000, it’s an action results in no harm done to the race. We’re not condoning or encouraging behaviour of that kind, but there’s a very small part of us that thinks it adds to the televisual spectacle as well. It’s impossible to imagine that this individual would have intended to knock off López, either.

 

Was the reaction of the Astana rider understandable? Of course it was. Can we imagine ourselves behaving similarly in even remotely similar circumstances? Absolutely.

 

Both individuals, we suspect, would go back in time and undo their respective actions if they could. Superman has already apologised. Nobody seems to have found the (reportedly Slovenian) fan who he swatted to extract a quote but it seems likely that he might be feeling somewhat remorseful (not to mention sore) as well. Surely there’s a fluffy little “reunion”-style story to be told there one day?

 

Read: Has the Tour de France fallen victim to the selfie generation?

 

No-one wants to see someone kicked out of a race but the letter of the law states that “acts of violence” by a rider “towards any other person [than a fellow rider]” will lead to “elimination and a 200[Swiss franc] fine”. There’s nothing currently in the rulebook that provides exception for provocation.

 

Even if you think there should be. Just as the Tour is the Tour, the law is the law. It can only be deemed fair – indeed it can only function – if it is applied without fear or favour. Fat chance with the UCI, you might (reasonably) think, but we can hope.

 

The post The column: Miguel Ángel López vs the Slovenian appeared first on The world's finest cycling magazine.

Giro d'Italia Giro d'Italia 2019 Miguel Angel Lopez Racing spectators

READ MORE

Giulio Ciccone

The crash that caused chaos: The Giro d'Italia has had an unexpected GC shake-up

On what was supposed to be a simple sprint finish, neither the fastmen nor many of the GC riders will be pleased with how the...

Read more
Giro d'Italia

Giro d'Italia 2025 stage 15 preview: Up and over Monte Grappa

A stage stacked full of climbing may not be enough to draw out the GC contenders, thanks to the long plateau to the finish

Read more
Isaac del Toro

Victory by a thousand paper cuts: Can Isaac del Toro's bonus seconds strategy lead to a Giro d'Italia win?

The Mexican has been the most impressive GC rider so far in this Giro, but will face his toughest test in the high mountains next...

Read more
Mads Pedersen

A sprint like no other: Mads Pedersen’s power rewrites uphill cycling rules

Lidl-Trek have five wins at the 2025 Giro d’Italia after Pedersen’s win on stage 13 in Vicenza

Read more
Olav Kooij at the Giro d'Italia 2025

Giro d'Italia 2025 stage 14 preview: Last sprint chance before Rome

The Giro's penultimate chance for the sprinters awaits on a flat finish in the Slovenian city of Nova Gorica

Read more
Explore without borders: Behind the Giro’s stage finish in the border city of Gorizia

Explore without borders: Behind the Giro’s stage finish in the border city of Gorizia

The twin cities of Gorizia and Nova Gorica straddle the border between Italy and Slovenia. Rouleur takes a couple of rides in a region with...

Read more

READ RIDE REPEAT

JOIN ROULEUR TODAY

Get closer to the sport than ever before.

Enjoy a digital subscription to Rouleur for just £4 per month and get access to our award-winning magazines.

SUBSCRIBE